Extra Extra Pizza Menu
63 items in 5 sections · $2.00 – $60.00 · Pizza Restaurant in Buffalo, NY
Extra Extra Pizza’s menu lists 63 dishes and drinks, grouped into Spirits, Not-Pizza, Our Picks, Sweet, and Others. Prices range from $2.00 to $60.00, and a typical item costs about $10.00. Popular choices include White Verjus, Bread + Butter, Pizza Number Ii, Lagunitas Hop Water, and Leitz Off Dry Riesling Can.
Spirits 7
- White Verjus$7.00
- Red Verjus$7.00
- Ritual Gin$6.00
- Ritual Tequila$10.00
- Lyre's Italian Orange$6.00
- Lemonade$4.00
- Basil Lemonade$5.00
Not-Pizza 6
- Bread + Butter$4.00
- Salad$13.00
- Olives$8.00
- Meatballs
- Giardiniera$4.00
- Cheesy Garlic Bread$2.00
Our Picks 2
- Pizza Number Ii$22.00
- Pizza Number 12$24.00
Sweet 7
- Leitz Off Dry Riesling Can
- G.d. Vajra Moscato D'asti
- Emma Off Dry Lambrusco
- Red Tail Ridge Good Karma Riesling
- Francoli Fernet
- Vecchia Amaro Del Capo
- Drink Number 5
Others 41
- Lagunitas Hop Water$4.00
- Athletic Brewing$7.00
- Phony Negroni$10.00
- Amaro Spritz$10.00
- Pellegrino 1l$8.00
- Proxies Sparkling Rose$11.00
- Unified Ferments Jasmine Kombucha$55.00
- Proxies Pink Salt Rosé
- Proxies Red Ember$11.00
- Bold Graceful: Black Cherry, Earthy$10.00
- Dark Rich: Blackberry, Coffee$60.00
- Drink Number 30$13.00
- Leitz Off Dry Riesling Can$13.00
- G.d. Vajra Moscato D'ast$26.00
- Emma Off Dry Lambrusco$45.00
- Walcher Amaretto$6.00
- Vecchia Limoncino$4.00
- Stambecco Cherry Amaro$6.00
- Stuffed Banana Pepper$23.00
- Chicago Beef$24.00
- Plush Easy: Black Cherry
- Soft Serve Ice Cream
- Two Robbers Craft Seltzer
- Anderson Valley Gose
- Wayland Baby Marzen
- Fiddlehead Ipa
- Allagash White
- Budweiser
- Busch N/A
- Athletic Brewing N/A
- Ven Trapp Pilsner
- Lagunitas Hop Water N/A
- Talea Pink Lemonade Lager
- Casa Lucciola Verdicchio De Matelica, Marche Italy
- Dinamo Nucleo 2 Bianco, Trebbiano, Umbria Italy
- Fabulas Cerasuolo D'abruzzo, Rose From Montepulciano, Abruzzo Italy
- Tart + Fizzy: #Pizzawine, Rough And Tumble
- Budweiser, Busch Na
- Thin Man Pils Mafia, Fiddlehead Ipa
- Athletic Brewing Golden Na
- Thin Man Minkey Boodle
How these prices compare
Based on 143 menus with 17,153 priced items from pizza restaurants in New York, the median menu item costs $14.75, and half of all items are priced between $9.00 and $22.95.
At Extra Extra Pizza the median listed price is $10.00, lower than the typical $14.75 for pizza restaurants in New York.
| Item | On menus | Typical price |
|---|---|---|
| Mozzarella Sticks | 58% | $9.95 |
| Caesar Salad | 56% | $11.65 |
| Baked Ziti | 50% | $16.00 |
| Garlic Bread | 49% | $5.50 |
| French Fries | 48% | $5.95 |
| Garlic Knots | 44% | $4.00 |
Typical prices are calculated from 143 menus in our guide.
Menu items and prices are provided for information and may have changed (last updated May 2026). Allergen information is not included – please ask the restaurant.