Extra Extra Pizza Menu
63 items in 5 sections · $2.00 – $60.00 · Pizza Restaurant in Buffalo, NY
Extra Extra Pizza’s menu lists 63 dishes and drinks, grouped into Spirits, Not-Pizza, Our Picks, Sweet, and Others. Prices range from $2.00 to $60.00, and a typical item costs about $10.00. Popular choices include White Verjus, Bread + Butter, Pizza Number Ii, Lagunitas Hop Water, and Leitz Off Dry Riesling Can.
Spirits 7
- White Verjus$7.00
- Red Verjus$7.00
- Ritual Gin$6.00
- Ritual Tequila$10.00
- Lyre's Italian Orange$6.00
- Lemonade$4.00
- Basil Lemonade$5.00
Not-Pizza 6
- Bread + Butter$4.00
- Salad$13.00
- Olives$8.00
- Meatballs
- Giardiniera$4.00
- Cheesy Garlic Bread$2.00
Our Picks 2
- Pizza Number Ii$22.00
- Pizza Number 12$24.00
Sweet 7
- Leitz Off Dry Riesling Can
- G.d. Vajra Moscato D'asti
- Emma Off Dry Lambrusco
- Red Tail Ridge Good Karma Riesling
- Francoli Fernet
- Vecchia Amaro Del Capo
- Drink Number 5
Others 41
- Lagunitas Hop Water$4.00
- Athletic Brewing$7.00
- Phony Negroni$10.00
- Amaro Spritz$10.00
- Pellegrino 1l$8.00
- Proxies Sparkling Rose$11.00
- Unified Ferments Jasmine Kombucha$55.00
- Proxies Pink Salt Rosé
- Proxies Red Ember$11.00
- Bold Graceful: Black Cherry, Earthy$10.00
- Dark Rich: Blackberry, Coffee$60.00
- Drink Number 30$13.00
- Leitz Off Dry Riesling Can$13.00
- G.d. Vajra Moscato D'ast$26.00
- Emma Off Dry Lambrusco$45.00
- Walcher Amaretto$6.00
- Vecchia Limoncino$4.00
- Stambecco Cherry Amaro$6.00
- Stuffed Banana Pepper$23.00
- Chicago Beef$24.00
- Plush Easy: Black Cherry
- Soft Serve Ice Cream
- Two Robbers Craft Seltzer
- Anderson Valley Gose
- Wayland Baby Marzen
- Fiddlehead Ipa
- Allagash White
- Budweiser
- Busch N/A
- Athletic Brewing N/A
- Ven Trapp Pilsner
- Lagunitas Hop Water N/A
- Talea Pink Lemonade Lager
- Casa Lucciola Verdicchio De Matelica, Marche Italy
- Dinamo Nucleo 2 Bianco, Trebbiano, Umbria Italy
- Fabulas Cerasuolo D'abruzzo, Rose From Montepulciano, Abruzzo Italy
- Tart + Fizzy: #Pizzawine, Rough And Tumble
- Budweiser, Busch Na
- Thin Man Pils Mafia, Fiddlehead Ipa
- Athletic Brewing Golden Na
- Thin Man Minkey Boodle
Menu items and prices are provided for information and may have changed (last updated May 2026). Allergen information is not included – please ask the restaurant.